The old list simply did not include it
The claim that trackers used to miss strength work is not a hunch. As of October 26, Google's own help page on which activities Fitbit devices and Pixel Watch track still showed the pre-update list for Fitbit Air and Pixel Watch 3, 4 and 5: walking, running, biking, sports, elliptical, rowing machine and stationary bike. Strength training is not there. If you lifted and wanted it in your record, you had to start the workout yourself or add it afterward. That page had not yet been refreshed for version 5.11 when we checked, so its list reflects the old behavior rather than the new one.
Why that gap matters more after 40
Strength work is not a niche add-on in federal guidance. The Physical Activity Guidelines for Americans say adults need muscle-strengthening activity, like lifting weights or doing push-ups, at least two days each week, alongside aerobic activity.
Yet it is the half of the guidelines fewer people meet. National survey data from the CDC's National Center for Health Statistics found that 31.0% of US adults met the muscle-strengthening guideline in 2020, and the share meeting both the aerobic and muscle-strengthening guidelines drops steadily with age, from 41.3% of men and 28.7% of women aged 18 to 34 down to 21.6% and 17.6% at ages 50 to 64.
Put those two facts together and the practical issue becomes clear. For many people in midlife, lifting is exactly the part of the week that takes the most intention, and it was also the part an activity tracker was least likely to notice. A record that shows every walk and none of your strength days can quietly suggest you are less active than you are. Automatic detection does not change the workout, but it can make your weekly picture more complete and more honest.
If you are newer to the weights side of things, our look at what happens to your body when you lift weights regularly covers the research on the changes people tend to notice over time.