One Formula, 20 Labels, and the Serving Sizes That Shrink the Sugar on the Label
Credit: Daily Vitality
Granola has one of the strongest health halos in the cereal aisle. The bags show oats, honey and almonds, and the front panels talk about whole grains and protein. So when you stand in front of twenty of them, it feels like you're choosing between good, better and best.
What you're actually choosing between is a set of labels that don't measure the same thing. One granola lists a quarter cup as a serving, another lists two thirds of a cup, and the per-serving numbers look comparable only because the portions aren't. We scored all 20 the same way, per 100 grams, using the published Daily Vitality Score, and then added the two columns the front of the bag leaves out: how big the declared serving really is, and how much added sugar lands in a standard 50 g pour.
The list counts down from 20 to 1, so the best score arrives last. Each entry shows its full breakdown, so you can see exactly where a granola gained or lost points and decide which trade-offs matter most at your breakfast table.
Every label was read on October 19, 2026. "Serving vs. 60 g" compares the declared serving with the FDA reference amount for granola, and "Added sugar per 50 g" puts every granola on the same standard pour.
Ties are ordered by the unrounded score.
The formula was first used on the chip aisle, and the scores are designed to be comparable across categories.
Lay's Chips vs. Doritos vs. SunChips: 16 Popular Chips Scored Out of 100
The Daily Vitality Score adds up nine parts to reach 100 points. Seventy-five points come from the Nutrition Facts panel: sodium (20), calories per 100 g (15), saturated fat (10) and added sugars (10), plus fiber and protein per 100 calories (10 each). The other 25 points come from the ingredient list: what the first ingredient is (10), how many ultra-processing markers appear (10) and how long the list runs (5). The nutrient end points are borrowed from the European Nutri-Score system, and the protein and fiber reference rates come from the FDA's Daily Values.
The marker count follows the NOVA definition of ultra-processed food, which names flavors, emulsifiers, sweeteners, protein isolates and added fibers among its markers. In granola, the ones that show up are natural flavor, soy lecithin, soy protein isolate, isolated fibers such as inulin and soluble corn fiber, fruit juice concentrate and the sweetener allulose. Honey, cane sugar, molasses, plain syrups and vanilla extract don't count. Each marker costs 2.5 points.
We read each manufacturer's or retailer's current label first and checked it against the USDA FoodData Central branded foods database. Seven of the 20 USDA records were out of date, described an older recipe or contained impossible values, so the current label was used every time.
For a plain-language explanation of what separates processed from ultra-processed food, there's a full guide.
Processed vs. Ultra-Processed Foods: What's the Difference?
As a cross-check, we also ran each granola through the 2023 Nutri-Score algorithm. The two rankings agreed closely (a rank correlation of 0.83), and the disagreements came mostly from the ingredient section, which Nutri-Score doesn't have.
The score compares granolas with each other. A 75 means a granola is one of the better options on this shelf, not that it fits every breakfast, and it isn't medical advice. Price isn't part of the score.
Under federal labeling rules, a ready-to-eat cereal weighing 43 g or more per cup has a reference amount of 60 g per eating occasion. Loose granola weighs roughly 100 to 130 g per cup, so 60 g is its yardstick. The 40 g figure you may have seen belongs to granola bars, a different category.
Six of these granolas declare 33 g or less. Nature Valley Crunchy Oats 'n Honey declares a quarter cup, or 27 g, which is 45% of the reference amount. Its 7 g of added sugar per serving sounds modest until you picture the bowl.
To picture it, we went to the government's own record of what people eat. In the latest National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey food records, covering 2021 to 2023, the typical granola eating occasion was 55 g at the median and 57.6 g on average, across 159 recorded occasions. Half of all occasions were 50 g or more. It's a small sample, so treat it as a guide rather than a precise number.
At that 55 g median, the Nature Valley pouch delivers about 14 g of added sugar. The FDA's Daily Value for added sugars is 50 g a day on a 2,000-calorie diet, so one ordinary bowl covers more than a quarter of it. That's why the scoreboard shows added sugar per 50 g: it puts the quarter-cup granolas and the two-thirds-cup granolas on the same footing.
You can see the same pour pattern across cereals in general in our ranking of cereals by fiber per dollar.
20 "Healthy" Cereals Ranked by Fiber Per Dollar — and Sugar Per Bowl
Score: 62 / 100 · Fair
The 16 oz pouch lists a 1/4 cup (27 g) serving with 7 g of added sugar, 1 g of fiber and 2 g of protein. Scaled to 100 g, that is 25.9 g of added sugar, the most in the set, and the lowest fiber rate of all 20.
This is the granola most people picture when they hear the brand name, and it has the smallest declared serving here. At a standard 50 g pour it carries 13 g of added sugar. Sugar is the second ingredient, followed by oil, rice flour, honey and brown sugar syrup, so the sweetness is built in at several points on the list.
What it does well is saturated fat, which stays low, and its sodium is moderate. The trade-off is that it gives you little fiber or protein to balance the sugar.
Score: 63 / 100 · Fair
On ingredients alone, Purely Elizabeth is one of the strongest granolas here. Its nine-ingredient list runs from organic oats and coconut sugar through coconut oil, seeds, amaranth, quinoa and chia, with no flavorings or additives at all.
The nutrition panel tells a different story. A 1/3 cup (30 g) serving has 3.5 g of saturated fat, which works out to 11.7 g per 100 g, past the formula's 10 g end point. That single line costs all 10 saturated fat points. Sodium is the highest in the set per 100 g, at 450 mg.
It is also the only granola here with a Nutri-Score E. If a short, recognizable ingredient list is what matters most to you, this one delivers it; the score simply shows what that list adds up to on the panel.
Score: 66 / 100 · Fair
This is the set's keto entry, built on almonds and sunflower seeds rather than oats. Its 1/3 cup (30 g) serving has 0 g of added sugar, 4 g of fiber and 5 g of protein, which earns full points on both added sugar and fiber.
So why is it third from the bottom? The sweetness comes from allulose, the fiber partly from tapioca fiber, and the protein partly from soy protein isolate, with natural flavor on top. Those are four separate ultra-processing markers, which empties the marker section. Nut-based granolas also run richer, and saturated fat lands at 6.7 g per 100 g.
It's a good illustration of how the formula works: taking sugar out by adding sweeteners and isolated fibers trades one deduction for another.
Score: 68 / 100 · Fair
Sweet Home Farm is a Post Consumer Brands label sold in 24 oz bags. A 1/2 cup serving lists 250 calories, 3 g of saturated fat and 10 g of added sugars, with just 20 mg of sodium.
That near-zero sodium earns every one of the 20 sodium points. The losses come from saturated fat, driven by coconut, and from energy density: at 472 calories per 100 g it is one of the richest oat-based granolas in the set. A cardamom, fennel and nutmeg spice blend gives it a warmer flavor than most honey-nut recipes, and natural flavor is the only marker.
Score: 69 / 100 · Fair
Love Crunch reads like a treat: dark chocolate chunks, cocoa, coconut and freeze-dried strawberries and raspberries. The current 11.5 oz bag lists a 1/4 cup (30 g) serving with 130 calories and 6 g of added sugar. An older USDA record for the same granola listed a half cup (55 g), so the declared portion has been cut roughly in half.
At a 50 g pour it delivers 10 g of added sugar. It also has the lowest protein rate in the set. The organic oats and fair-trade chocolate earn ingredient points, and chocolate flavor is the single marker.
Score: 70 / 100 · Good
Costco's organic granola mixes oats with Kamut khorasan wheat, spelt, quinoa and amaranth. A 3/4 cup (55 g) serving carries 8 g of added sugar and 6 g of fiber according to a photo of the current panel, which matches USDA's record and the 6 g of fiber Costco advertises.
Its added sugar per 100 g is among the lowest of the oat granolas, and the fiber rate is the fourth-best in the set. Part of that fiber comes from added inulin, which counts as a marker alongside natural vanilla flavor, and 16 ingredients cost most of the list-length points. The current version also adds a probiotic culture, which the score doesn't account for either way.
Score: 70 / 100 · Good
Michele's is a small Maryland granola maker, and its Original recipe is the kind you could make at home: organic oats, brown sugar, canola oil, sunflower seeds, almonds, unsweetened coconut and vanilla extract. There's no salt at all, so sodium is a clean 20 points, and there are no markers.
The panel is where it gives points back. A 1/4 cup (28 g) serving holds 140 calories and 2 g of saturated fat, which works out to 500 calories and 7.1 g of saturated fat per 100 g, the highest energy density in the set. Its declared serving is also one of the smallest, at 47% of the reference amount.
Score: 70 / 100 · Good
The front of the bag promises 13 g of protein, and the 2/3 cup (65 g) panel delivers it, along with 15 g of added sugars and 280 calories. Its protein rate, 4.6 g per 100 calories, is the highest of all 20.
The protein comes mostly from soy protein isolate, the third ingredient, and that is one of three markers along with soy lecithin and natural flavor. Sugar is the second ingredient. Nature Valley's own reduced-sugar packaging names this granola as its leading product at 16 g of sugar per 65 g.
The result is a granola that wins clearly on one nutrient and gives back most of that lead on sugar and ingredients.
To see how protein claims on the front of the box compare with the panel more broadly, there's a full breakdown here.
Behind the Hype: Does 'High Protein' on the Front of the Box Mean Anything?
Score: 71 / 100 · Good
Kellogg's Low Fat Granola is now sold at retail as a single-serve package. The 2.219 oz (63 g) package lists 240 calories, 1 g of saturated fat, 18 g of total sugars and 14 g of added sugars. The multigrain version in larger boxes is now a foodservice item.
The low-fat promise holds: it has the lowest energy density in the set. But sugar, raisins and brown rice syrup all appear in the first four ingredients, and added sugar per 100 g is among the higher readings. Modified food starch (a thickener) and natural flavors are its two markers.
Score: 71 / 100 · Good
Cascadian Farm keeps it simple: whole grain oats, cane sugar, rice, sunflower oil, honey, molasses, sea salt and natural flavor, all organic. A 2/3 cup serving has 270 calories, 14 g of added sugars and 3 g of fiber.
The short list and single marker earn solid ingredient points. The panel is the limit: 3 g of fiber in a bowl-sized serving gives it the second-lowest fiber rate of all 20, and added sugar sits at 22.6 g per 100 g. It's a reminder that organic certification describes how ingredients are grown, not how much sugar the recipe uses.
Score: 71 / 100 · Good
Target's French Vanilla Almond granola lists a 2/3 cup serving with 280 calories, 80 mg of sodium, 15 g of added sugars and 5 g of protein. The bag also prints a second column for a 32 g snack portion, about 1/3 cup.
It lands within a fraction of a point of Cascadian Farm. Sodium is low and there's only one marker, but added sugar is the second-highest per 100 g in the set and protein is on the low side. At a 50 g pour it delivers 11.9 g of added sugar.
Score: 72 / 100 · Good
Bear Naked's Fit line is the brand's lower-sugar option, and the current 1/2 cup (52 g) panel shows 220 calories and 7 g of added sugars. That's one of the lower added-sugar readings in the set.
Sodium pulls it back. The current label lists 180 mg per serving, up from 150 mg on an older version, which works out to 346 mg per 100 g. Protein is modest at 5 g. The ingredient list of oats, almonds, brown sugar, brown rice syrup and crisp rice carries only one marker, natural flavors.
Score: 74 / 100 · Good
On nutrients alone, Quaker Simply Granola scores 60.2 of 75, the best panel in the set. Its 2/3 cup (68 g) serving has 7 g of fiber, 35 mg of sodium and 9 g of added sugars.
That last figure deserves a closer look. Total sugars are 16 g, but the raisins account for much of it, and the score counts only added sugar. The serving is also the largest in the set, at 113% of the reference amount.
The ingredient list is where it slips. Sixteen ingredients include whey, whey protein concentrate, inulin and natural flavor, three distinct markers that cost 7.5 points.
If you're weighing granola against other quick breakfasts on protein and fiber, a side-by-side comparison is here.
The 10-Minute Breakfast Test: 12 Breakfasts Scored on Protein, Fiber, Cost and Minutes
Score: 74 / 100 · Good
A 1/2 cup (60 g) serving lists 280 calories, 11 g of protein and 10 g of added sugars, with only 80 mg of sodium. The protein comes partly from whole roasted soybeans and partly from soy protein isolate.
It shares much of its recipe with Bear Naked's Original Cinnamon, ranked fourth, but swaps the cranberries and sunflower seeds for almonds. That raises fat and energy density to 467 calories per 100 g, which costs points on calories and saturated fat. Nine ingredients keep the list relatively short.
Score: 75 / 100 · Good
KIND's peanut butter clusters list a 2/3 cup (65 g) bowl with 260 calories, 10 g of protein and 11 g of added sugars. The label also prints a 1/3 cup snack column.
Peanut butter, peanuts and peanut flour supply part of the protein, and soy protein isolate supplies the rest. That isolate is the only marker, so this granola keeps more ingredient points than Nature Valley's protein option while landing at a similar protein rate. Sixteen ingredients, mostly grains such as millet, buckwheat, amaranth and quinoa, cost most of the list-length points.
Score: 75 / 100 · Good
A long ingredient list isn't always a processed one. KIND's Oats & Honey with Toasted Coconut has 16 ingredients, and every one is a grain, a sweetener, coconut, oil or salt. There's no flavoring, emulsifier or isolate, so it keeps all 10 marker points.
A 2/3 cup (65 g) serving has 250 calories, 35 mg of sodium and 11 g of added sugars, with one of the lowest energy densities in the set. Protein is the weak spot at 5 g per bowl. It edges its peanut-butter sibling by less than half a point.
Score: 76 / 100 · Good
Some stores now sell this bag as Bear Naked Cinnamon Protein Granola. Its 1/2 cup (59 g) serving lists 260 calories, 1 g of saturated fat, 100 mg of sodium, 5 g of fiber, 10 g of added sugars and 11 g of protein.
No single line is the best in the set, but none is weak either. That evenness is what lifts it above the other protein granolas. Roasted soybeans, flax and sunflower seeds help the fiber and protein, and the two markers are soy protein isolate and natural flavor. Dried cranberries add some sweetness without pushing added sugar past the middle of the pack.
Score: 77 / 100 · Good
Nature Valley finishes both last and third. The reduced-sugar version lists a 2/3 cup (65 g) serving with 7 g of added sugars and 10 g of fiber. That's the lowest added sugar of any oat granola here and the best fiber rate of all 20.
Much of that fiber comes from soluble corn fiber, the second ingredient. Because NOVA treats isolated fibers as a processing marker, the granola earns full fiber points on the panel and gives some back in the ingredient section. Even so, it has the best nutrient score of the top three and the only Nutri-Score B in the set.
If you like the flagship pouch's flavor and want less added sugar, the reduced-sugar line is the closest swap in the same brand: per 50 g, it carries 5.4 g of added sugar compared with 13 g.
Score: 78 / 100 · Good
Bob's Red Mill's Classic Granola lists a 1/2 cup (54 g) serving with 220 calories, 3 g of fat, 0 mg of sodium, 5 g of fiber, 12 g of added sugars and 6 g of protein. Seven ingredients: oats, cane sugar, brown rice, a pineapple, pear and peach concentrate, oat syrup solids, vanilla extract and tocopherols.
There's no added oil in the list, which keeps fat low, and no salt at all. Added sugar is the clear weak spot, at 12 g per serving and 11.1 g per 50 g pour. The fruit juice concentrate is counted as a marker under NOVA. Fiber and protein are both above the middle of the pack.
Score: 81 / 100 · Good
The top score goes to the plainest granola on the shelf. Back to Nature's gluten-free Classic Granola lists five ingredients: whole grain rolled oats, brown rice syrup, cane sugar, vanilla extract and mixed tocopherols. A 1/3 cup (33 g) serving has 130 calories, 0 g of saturated fat, 0 mg of sodium and 5 g of added sugars.
It collects full points on sodium, saturated fat, first ingredient and markers, and nearly full points on list length. Where it doesn't lead is fiber and protein: 2 g and 3 g per serving put both on the low side of the set. And its declared serving is small, at 55% of the reference amount, so a 50 g pour holds 7.6 g of added sugar rather than the 5 g on the label.
Two practical notes. The 12.5 oz bag is a newer gluten-free recipe, and USDA's record still describes an older juice-sweetened version. And Back to Nature's own website no longer lists granola, though major grocers still stock it.
Three patterns run through all 20 granolas.
The serving size is doing a lot of work. Six granolas declare 33 g or less, while the FDA reference amount is 60 g and the typical recorded granola occasion is 55 g. Per 50 g, added sugar ranges from 0 g to 13 g, a spread that per-serving numbers mostly hide.
Every granola loses points on energy density. Even the leanest, Kellogg's Low Fat, lands at 381 calories per 100 g, and the richest reach 500. Granola is a concentrated food by design, which is why no product here reaches the Excellent band.
Protein claims come with trade-offs. The four granolas with the highest protein rates all rely at least partly on soy protein isolate, which counts as a marker and costs ingredient points. The one that balanced protein best, Bear Naked Original Cinnamon, did it with roasted soybeans and seeds as well.
The same scoring approach has been applied to other aisles too, which makes it easy to compare a granola's score with a snack's.
Cheez-It vs. Goldfish vs. Ritz: 18 Popular Crackers Scored Out of 100
About the Author
Angela Nightingale is a Senior Editor at Daily Vitality with over two decades of experience in digital publishing and health and wellness content. She specializes in turning complex, often-confusing health topics into clear, calm, and practical guidance that respects the reader's intelligence. Her work focuses on helping people feel informed and confident — never overwhelmed or alarmed — as they make everyday decisions about how they eat, move, rest, and age.
Back to Nature Classic Granola scored 81, followed by Bob's Red Mill Classic at 78 and Nature Valley Reduced Sugar Vanilla Almond at 77. All three are in the Good band.
Nature Valley Crunchy Oats 'n Honey scored 62, mainly because of high added sugar per 100 g and the lowest fiber rate in the set. Purely Elizabeth Original was close behind at 63.
Declared servings in this set range from 27 g to 68 g. Comparing per serving would compare different amounts of food. Per 100 g puts every granola on the same footing.
FDA labeling rules give ready-to-eat cereals weighing 43 g or more per cup a reference amount of 60 g. Loose granola falls in that group. Brands then express their serving in a household measure such as a cup fraction.
In national food records from 2021 to 2023, the median granola eating occasion was 55 g and the average was 57.6 g. That's about twice the 27 g to 33 g servings some labels declare.
Not automatically. Protein granolas earn more protein points, but several rely on soy protein isolate, which counts as an ultra-processing marker, and Nature Valley's version carries 15 g of added sugar per bowl. Nature Valley's protein granola scored 70, while Bear Naked Original Cinnamon scored 76.
KIND ZEROg has 0 g of added sugar and scored 66. It earned full points for sugar and fiber but lost all marker points because it uses allulose, tapioca fiber, soy protein isolate and natural flavor.
Coconut oil pushes its saturated fat to 11.7 g per 100 g, which earns zero saturated fat points. Its sodium per 100 g is also the highest in the set.
Added sugar. US labels list it separately, so sugar from raisins or other fruit isn't penalized. That's why Quaker Simply Granola, with 16 g of total sugar but 9 g added, scores well on sugar.
Not in this set. Good & Gather scored 71 and Kirkland Signature scored 70, in the same range as Cascadian Farm, Kellogg's and Nature Valley's protein granola.
Yes. Labels were read on October 19, 2026. Several had changed since USDA's records were last updated, including sodium on Bear Naked Fit and added sugar on Purely Elizabeth. A reformulated product gets re-scored.
