A few popular remedies show up in nearly every social media thread about cold sores. Knowing what to skip can be just as useful as knowing what to use.
Lysine supplements are a perennial favorite, but the evidence does not back the enthusiasm. A 2015 Cochrane review of cold sore prevention measures concluded that the available evidence does not support lysine supplementation as an effective preventive strategy for herpes labialis. A separate narrative review of lysine for herpes simplex prophylaxis came to a similar conclusion: the existing trials are inconsistent, dosing varies widely, and current data do not justify routine use. Lysine is generally safe, so people who feel it helps them are not putting themselves at risk by continuing — but it should not be relied on as a primary strategy.
Dabbing toothpaste on a cold sore is another widely shared tip with no clinical support. Most toothpastes contain sodium lauryl sulfate, a foaming agent that can irritate already-broken skin and is more likely to slow healing than to speed it.
Picking at the scab, popping the blister, or aggressively scrubbing the area is counterproductive. Dermatology guidance from major medical organizations consistently advises against it because it spreads viral fluid to other parts of the face, increases the risk of a secondary bacterial infection, and delays healing.
Applying undiluted essential oils like tea tree or peppermint directly to a cold sore is also worth avoiding. There is limited evidence of benefit and a real risk of contact dermatitis on the open lesion. Better-studied options exist and are easier on the skin.
A note on propolis: it is a more interesting case than the items above. Small trials of standardized propolis lip creams have shown promising results, and propolis is more credible than lysine or essential oils. Still, the body of evidence is smaller and product standardization is uneven, which is why it does not yet sit comfortably among the nine evidence-backed options above.